This activity made me think about what my own responses would be to a similar assessment. If I am answering honestly and truly considering how I think and learn, I would say I am a structured thinker; I like to keep my thought process in order. I tend to make charts and organize my learning so each new topic flows together and build on each other. I am autonomous and a self-starter. I like to make my own decisions, and have the confidence to do so. When needed, I can take my learning into my own hands. I would say, much Rupali, my need for complexity varies by situation. For instance, when I am solving a math equation, I most enjoy problems that are layered and require multiple skills and steps to solve.
But here's the catch... If I was younger, even just a few years younger as a high school student, I don't think I would make this honest assessment. How I think and learn, and how I wanted to do these were two very different things. I always wanted to be a creative person; I took a variety of art, photography, and creative writing class through high school and undergrad because, that was the person I wanted to be. In elementary school I was in band and chorus, I "sketched" fashion designs, and I started an all girls pop group with my best friends. We were going to be famous! I didn't think about the fact that I was completely tone deaf, couldn't draw, and had a terrible singing voice (I can prove it).
I should mention now that I was a math major, something very analytical and certain, not at all creative. I was always a strong math student, even in elementary school. I appreciated that there was one right answer and a specific chain of events that you needed to follow to get there. I could remember the steps needed to solve complicated algebra problems and I would do it quickly. Even when I started college, I was on the fence about being an English major. I wanted that creative lifestyle.
So where am I going with all of this?... It took me until I was 20 years old to accept that I was a very analytical thinker and learner. As a future elementary school teacher, I will be working with students from ages 5 to 12. There is such a slim chance that these students will be able to honestly tell me how they think and learn. Thus, it is nearly impossible to get an authentic self-assessment from them. I think a large percent of the students will be like me and answer the questions based on what kind of minds they want to have, not how their minds really process information. I am not complete discarding the validity of an activity like this. In fact, I do think it would be interesting to do maybe halfway through the year when I have had a chance to work with students and see how they learn best. I would already have an idea of the group going into the assessment and could see how accurately students perceive their learning.
Here is a quick quiz you can take to see what learning style you fall under. Answer honestly! And if you complete it, please comment and let me know what style you got and how accurate you think it is.